‘Hunters of Earth’ (DOTD) (Audio)

dwdotd01_huntersofearth_1417_cover_large dotd-complete

‘HUNTERS OF EARTH’ (DOTD)

Please feel free to comment on my review.

Tribute for William Hartnell – Celebrating 50 Years of ‘Doctor Who’

It’s the 50th anniversary of ‘Doctor Who’!

January, 2013. It’s time to celebrate the First Doctor era of ‘Doctor Who’ with William Hartnell!

I was introduced to ‘Doctor Who’ by my Dad, as William Hartnell was his Doctor. I’ve seen the First Doctor’s stories from the ‘The Beginning’ DVD box set to ‘The Reign of Terror’ on DVD. For the 50th anniversary of ‘Doctor Who’, I wrote my personal fan-fiction story with the First Doctor; Ian; Barbara and Susan to celebrate the First Doctor era.

Of course, this ties in to the audio CD series to celebrate the 50th anniversary of ‘Doctor Who’. This CD audio series is called ‘Destiny of the Doctor’ and it was produced both by Big Finish and AudioGo. I was thrilled to bits when I heard about this new series of audios from January to November, 2013.

I love the Big Finish audios and I was looking forward to the fact that this series of audios would feature the first eleven Doctors with an adventure from William Hartnell’s Doctor to Matt Smith’s Doctor. It fulfilled the 50th anniversary for me with the absence of a multi-Doctor story for that year.

The ‘Destiny of the Doctor’ series starts with celebrating the First Doctor era in ‘Hunters of Earth’ by Nigel Robinson. This story features the First Doctor with his granddaughter Susan. ‘Hunters of Earth’ is performed/narrated by Carole Ann Ford as Susan from the TV series and guest stars Tam Williams as Cedric.

I’ve had the CD cover of ‘Hunters of Earth’ signed by Carole Ann Ford, who I met her at the ‘Project Motor Mouth 2’ convention in Slough, August 2013. I didn’t get to chat to Carole much, but it was nice to meet her.

‘Hunters of Earth’ is set prior to ‘An Unearthly Child’. It takes place at Coal Hill School in Shoreditch, London 1963 where the First Doctor and Susan first come to Earth. The Doctor needs to repair the TARDIS. Susan attends to Coal Hill School in order to avoid attention, to which inevitably she does.

This story certainly has a 1960s feel to it. Nigel Robinson clearly is the right person to pen this tale. The 1960s elements are all here, from the Beatles; to transistor radios; to Eagle comics and students at coffee shops. It’s a nostalgic tale with echoes of London recovering from the Second World War.

‘Hunters of Earth’ is told in the style of a Companion Chronicle from Big Finish. But instead of the story told from Susan’s point of view, it’s narrated in the third person in a ‘Lost Stories’ style of story-telling. Carole Ann Ford narrates the story and plays Susan, the Doctor and many other characters.

Carole Ann Ford is a superb narrator. She kept me engaged whilst she both read and performed as Susan in this story. I like how this story focuses on Susan’s story when she lives in 60s London with her grandfather and when she debates whether to stay and fit in with everyone at Coal Hill School.

I enjoyed hearing how the First Doctor was portrayed in this story. This is the amoral, dismissive; superior; alien version of the First Doctor before ‘An Unearthly Child’. The Doctor is disregarding the human race of Earth in 1963, but I like the loving relationship he has with his granddaughter, Susan.

Tam Williams guest stars as Cedric, a young man who befriends Susan at Coal Hill School. The relationship between Susan and Cedric was nice to hear and it felt like a close friendship. But as the plot thickens, there are twists between Susan and Cedric and the revelation is quite heart-breaking.

A future Doctor makes an appearance in this adventure with the First Doctor and Susan. This occurs in a scene at the coffee shop where the First Doctor and Susan hear a message on the radio. I wasn’t sure what the message was about and which future Doctor it was, but apparently it’s ‘all in the beat’.

The climax to ‘Hunters of Earth’ was so captivating and exciting to listen to. The Doctor and Susan get to solve the problem as they put their minds to it. I liked how this story had kept the First Doctor and Susan’s origins in the dark since they were presented as enigmas throughout in the TV series.

Susan’s prophecy about the Doctor’s destiny at the end of ‘Hunters of Earth’ was quite chilling and interesting to listen to. It made me wonder what was going to happen in future releases of the ‘Destiny of the Doctor’ series and how it was going to end. I would have to find out later on the year.

There aren’t any CD extras, apart from the First Doctor and Susan’s biographies in the CD sleeve notes. If you purchase the complete ‘DOTD’ series as a bundle from Big Finish, there’s a behind-the-scenes making-of documentary on the series called ‘Meeting with Destiny’ with ‘The Time Machine’.

‘Hunters of Earth’ is a good start to the beginning of the 50th anniversary celebrations in the ‘Destiny of the Doctor’ series. This story feels like it came from the black-and-white days of ‘Doctor Who’. With Carole Ann Ford as Susan and the narrator of this story, it captured the First Doctor era for me.

‘Hunters of Earth (DOTD)’ rating – 8/10


The previous story

For the First Doctor was

  • ‘Quinnis’ (Audio)

For Susan was

  • ‘Quinnis’ (Audio)
The next story

For the ‘Destiny of the Doctor’ series is

For the First Doctor is

For Susan is

Return to Doctor Who Reviews

5 Responses to ‘Hunters of Earth’ (DOTD) (Audio)

  1. IWishIHadATardis says:

    Hi Tim

    I really enjoyed reading your review of Hunters of Earth. I found this story really innovative and most interesting to listen to, and I look forward to relistening to the DOTD range of stories.

    It was really great to have the Common Men references, and the very good cultural references, with the atmosphere of London in the 1960s really well done, I thought.

    This is a really good First Doctor story, and Carole Ann Ford does a wonderful job performing the story; a very evocative story, which made me think fondly of William Hartnell’s era, and those wonderful black and white stories.

    Great stuff, Tim.

    Leigh

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Tim Bradley says:

    Hi Leigh.

    Thanks for your kind comments on my DOTD reviews. I’m glad you enjoyed my review of ‘Hunters of Earth’. I relistened to it recently and was amazed at how well-performed it was by Carole Ann Ford and I’m glad you found it innovate and most interesting.

    Yes the atmosphere of 1963 worked well in this story and I liked the references to the Beatles and the Common Men. This was all before ‘1963: Fanfare For The Common Men’ where the Fifth Doctor and Nyssa would meet them, so it was great to have them referrenced in this audio story as part of the DOTD range.

    Yes this story did well to celebrate the First Doctor era and it was nice to have a stoy set before ‘An Unearthly Child’ and find out more about what the Doctor and Susan were doing on Earth in 1963 and what school-life was like for Susan at Coal Hill. The Doctor is at his most superior and arrogant by this point in this story, isn’t he?

    I’m glad you enjoyed my review on ‘Hunters of Earth’. Thanks again for your kind comments.

    Tim. 🙂

    Like

  3. IWishIHadATardis says:

    I really must re-listen to these DOTD stories, they really are great for reminiscing, aren’t they? They seem to bring together all the elements that make each of the individual Doctors so special, and encapsulate them in their individual stories.

    I really did like the idea of having the Doctor and Susan in 1963 and before the adventures that we have previously been aware of. I liked that the Doctor, although haughty and superior in his attitudes, also shows a great cleverness in his dealings with the situation, and a nice cunning approach, which I think is so much part of this FIrst Doctor – suspicious, and protective of Susan above all else.

    You’re welcome, Tim, it was a great read.
    Leigh

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Timelord 007 says:

    Great opener to the DOTD series, i found this a really gripping story post tv series.

    As ever a brilliantly written review which is extremely helpful especially for casual Who fans.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Tim Bradley says:

    Thanks Timelord Simon for your comments. Yes this was a great story to open the DOTD series and very fitting to celebrate the First Doctor era of ‘Doctor Who’ for the 50th anniversary.

    Very pleased you enjoyed my review, Timelord. I’m glad you find my review helpful for casual ‘Doctor Who’ fans.

    Thanks. Tim. 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s