‘The Impossible Astronaut’/’Day of the Moon’ (TV)

51a5r8ravvl-_ac_ul320_sr228320_  51n1xyjqmkl-_ac_ul320_sr226320_


Please feel free to comment on my review.

Silence will Fall!

The Doctor, Amy and Rory are back!

This is Series 6 of ‘Doctor Who’, starring Matt Smith; Karen Gillan; Arthur Darvill and Alex Kingston! It was Matt Smith’s second season in the new series of ‘Doctor Who’ and has thirteen episodes. Series 6 was divided into two parts as Part 1 was shown in the spring of 2011 with the first seven episodes.

I have vivid memories of watching this series in 2011. This isn’t my favourite series of ‘Doctor Who’. I found Series 6 to be a rather convoluted series of stories. There was a story arc about the Doctor’s death that permeated the whole of Series 6. I felt it was too confusing and it had me feel unsatisfied.


Lately, I’ve re-watched Series 6 of ‘Doctor Who’ to get a better understanding of the stories. I’m clearer about what’s going on, but I wish it was clearer from the first time I saw Series 6. It seemed to me that Steven Moffat was trying to be too clever as he makes it a huge puzzle for the audience.

I don’t know whether children who have viewed this series would have understood the stories. I thought the science-fiction concepts were difficult for kids to understand. But there are some good moments to be found in Series 6 as well as the bad, which I hope to explain while I review this series.



N.B. Watch the prequel for ‘The Impossible Astronaut’ before this episode.

This first episode of Series 6 is the first of a two-part story by Steven Moffat to open the series. It is set in America and the Doctor with Amy, Rory and River Song go off on an adventure to Space: 1969.

This is an interesting episode to start the series. When I say interesting, it’s where the story arc of the Doctor’s death starts…with the Doctor actually dying in this episode. Are you still with me on this?


In 2011, the Doctor summons his friends Amy and Rory to meet him in America. Having not seen him for a long time, Amy and Rory respond to the Doctor’s summons. River Song is also summoned too.

Whilst having a picnic on a beach in Utah, the Doctor and his friends see a strange astronaut walk up from the sea. The Doctor goes to meet it and is soon shot by the astronaut before he ends up dead.

Shocked and upset, Amy; Rory and River see the Doctor burned out to sea. Believing the Doctor to be no more, the three friends are shocked and surprised when they see the Doctor alive at a diner.


It turns out that the Doctor who died on the beach in Utah is a version from the future. The Doctor that Amy; Rory and River meet in the diner is an earlier version who doesn’t know he’s going to die.

This is where it gets complicated, as Steven Moffat sets in motion a puzzle on what will happen to lead to the Doctor’s demise in the series. Unanswered questions are made at the end of this story.

Matt Smith returns as the Doctor in this series. It was interesting how the Doctor gets killed at the beginning of the series only to return alive and well later on. I did wonder what would happen to him.


Karen Gillan returns as Amy. I liked those moments when Amy is distraught at seeing the Doctor’s death on the Utah and when she asks the Doctor to put his trust in her by saying ‘fish fingers and custard’.

Arthur Darvill returns as Rory, the faithful husband of Amy. I was pleased to see Rory more involved in the series and as a proper companion after Series 5. I liked it when Rory is clearly out of his depth.

Alex Kingston returns as River Song. There’s still a mystery going on about her with who she is and what she means to the Doctor. There’s this promise about who River truly is later on in the series.


The guest cast also includes Mark Sheppard as FBI agent Canton Everett Delaware III; William Morgan Sheppard (Mark Sheppard’s father) as older Canton and Stuart Milligan as President Nixon.

This story features the first appearance of the Silence, a new terrifying and scary monster. The Silence are terrifying when you look at them. But when you look away, you completely forget them.

The first episode ends on a cliff-hanger that is very unusual. Amy reveals that she is pregnant! Hey?!


The DVD special features on this episode are as follows. On Disc 2 of ‘The Complete Series 6’ of ‘Doctor Who’, there’s a commentary with Arthur Darvill; producer Marcus Wilson and line producer David Mason. There’s the prequel for ‘The Impossible Astronaut’ with Stuart Milligan as Mr Nixon.

On Disc 6, there’s the ‘Doctor Who Confidential’ episode ‘Coming to America’.

‘DAY OF THE MOON’ (Part 2)


The second episode takes place three months later since ‘The Impossible Astronaut’.

It begins with an unusual opening sequence as Amy, Rory and River are running for their lives by Canton Delaware.  I found it a shock and a surprise when Canton shoots the Doctor’s companions.

But it turns out that Canton hasn’t turned bad at all. He was helping the Doctor and his friends by sealing them in a prison made of dwarf star alloy to hide from the Silence and get into the TARDIS.


In the three months since the first episode, the Doctor, Amy, Rory, River and Canton have been trying to find out what these Silence monsters are all about. They’re about to get closer to the truth.

I found the concepts of the Silence monsters interesting. They seem to edit themselves out of your memory when you look away. They also seem an impossible enemy to defeat when they’re on Earth.

The Silence are terrifying, as the notion of them always there in Earth’s history and manipulating people subconsciously is shuddering. But the Doctor and his friends may have a way to sort them out.


I liked it when the Doctor plants a nanorecorder in the hands of his friends to record audios of their meetings with the Silence. They also mark tallies on their arms and faces to help them to remember.

Canton and Amy soon visit an orphanage where they hope to find the little girl inside the astronaut suit. The orphanage scenes at night were creepy, especially with the Silence up on the ceiling like bats.

Amy experiences some strange things during her visit to the orphanage. As well as seeing the Silence, she also sees an Eye-Patch Lady in a window and a photo of her as a mum with a baby.


It was pretty tense when the astronaut enters the little’s girl bedroom with Amy inside. Amy is scared and can’t understand what the little girl means to her before she gets taken away by Silence.

It was emotional when Rory finds Amy’s recording device and she’s still speaking. He wonders who she’s confessing her love for and it gets very tense, as it could have been either the Doctor or Rory.

I liked that some of this story was set in 1969, when the Apollo moon landing between Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin took place. This was something I studied at school as a kid and I knew the event well.


This was an interesting take on the special space event, as footage of the Silence is used during the TV transmission of the first moon landing. Soon everyone knows the Silence and a revolution begins.

Eventually, the Silence are silenced. I was pleased when it was Rory that Amy confessed her love to and I found it very interesting that the Silence’s control room was similar to the one in ‘The Lodger’.

This two-part ‘astronaut’ story has been enjoyable. Although there are a lot of unanswered questions about who River Song is; whether Amy is pregnant or not and why the little girl at the end is regenerating…


The DVD special features on this episode are as follows. On Disc 1 of ‘Series 6 – Part 1’, there’s the ‘Monster File: The Silence’, which looks into the creation and development of these new monsters.

On Disc 2 of ‘The Complete Series 6’ of ‘Doctor Who’, the ‘Monster File: The Silence’ can also be found on there. On Disc 6, there’s the ‘Doctor Who Confidential’ episode ‘Breaking the Silence’.

‘The Impossible Astronaut’/’Day of the Moon’ rating – 6/10

The previous story

For the Eleventh Doctor was

  • ‘The Way Through The Woods’ (Book/Audio)

For Amy was

  • ‘The Way Through The Woods’ (Book/Audio)

For Rory was

  • ‘The Way Through The Woods’ (Book/Audio)

For River Song was

The next story

For the Eleventh Doctor is

For Amy is

For Rory is

For River Song is

  • ‘The Pandorica Opens’/’The Big Bang’ (TV)
Return to Doctor Who Reviews

3 thoughts on “‘The Impossible Astronaut’/’Day of the Moon’ (TV)

  1. Brilliantly reviewed Tim, Moffat always over complicates his stories instead of focusing on the main concepts of the actual plot, no joke but Moffat could learn a thing or too from you Tim as you know exactly how to pace a story, build momentum, write interesting characters & deliver a great conclusion.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Simon.

    Thanks for your comments on my latest Series 6 reviews of ‘Doctor Who’. Glad you agree with my thoughts on this series. This story particularly was the beginning of two many complicated things happening in Steven Moffat’s era. I can see that Moffat tries to be too clever with his stories and it doesn’t really help in connecting with the audience. I’ve met fans and casual viewers who feel that same way as I do about his stories.

    I would like to write my own new series of ‘Doctor Who’ stories with my own Doctor and companion as I can imagine what the story arc would be about and how it could develop into something engaging and exciting for the audience to tune into. And of course I would bring Nyssa and Tegan back to add to the development of that story arc I have in mind. 😀 And perhaps cast Charles Dance as the Master! 😀

    Tim. 🙂


  3. Your stories immediately hook the reader in & I like how you write three hander dialogue with the Doctor, Nyssa & Billy then expand the supporting characters & plot, you are really talented writer Tim I don’t think you realise how actually brilliant you are, Doom Of The Daleks literally gave me goosebumps & is one of my all time favourite stories.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s