‘The Sontaran Experiment’ (TV)

the sontaran experiment dvd

‘THE SONTARAN EXPERIMENT’

Please feel free to comment on my review.

Sontaran in Dartmoor

This is a two-part story featuring one Sontaran!

‘The Sontaran Experiment’ was something very enthralling; entertaining and compelling. I wouldn’t class this as one of my favourite ‘Doctor Who’ stories, but it’s a nice little adventure with a Sontaran.

This two-part story is by the Bristol boys, Bob Baker and Dave Martin, who filled the gap between ‘The Ark in Space’ and ‘Genesis of the Daleks’. It depicts the Sontarans in a horrifying and disturbing way compared how the Sontarans were depicted previously in their debut story, ‘The Time Warrior’.

the sontaran experiment part 2

Set in the far future, the Doctor, Sarah Jane Smith and Harry Sullivan arrive on Earth following the events of ‘The Ark In Space’. They find what is left of the human race terribly tortured and on the run from the Sontaran, Field Major Styre who is on the planet, conducting terrible experiments on them.

I found the idea of a Sontaran major experimenting on human subjects for military purposes interesting and disturbing. The fact that Styre is testing the humans’ limits before allowing the Sontaran fleet to invade Earth is a frightening concept and it’s very compelling in just two episodes.

Kevin Lindsay, who played Linx the Sontaran in ‘The Time Warrior’, returns as Styre in ‘The Sontaran Experiment’. Styre is a darker and grim Sontaran character compared to Linx. Kevin does a fine job, bringing the same Sontaran strength and menace into Styre as he did for Linx in ‘The Time Warrior’.

Sontaran_Experiment

I’m not a fan though of the new Sontaran make-up featured in ‘The Sontaran Experiment’. It’s grey and pale and it should be brown and warty as it was from ‘The Time Warrior’. Kevin Lindsay died shortly after he played Styre, which is sad as he had a bad heart condition when he was in that story.

The fact that the whole story is filmed on location makes the story fast-paced and gripping to see. The Dartmoor landscape provide an atmospheric quality to ‘The Sontaran Experiment’ as the Doctor; Sarah Jane and Harry tread rugged terrain when encountering Styre and the other horrors on Earth.

I enjoyed Tom Baker as the Doctor. Tom accidentally injured his collarbone when he was making this story on location. The Doctor fares well though, especially when he fights Styre in a single combat in ‘Part Two’ that was exciting to watch (although that was a stuntman fighting as the Doctor, ha, ha).

the sontaran experiment part 1

I also liked Elisabeth Sladen as Sarah Jane Smith. The scene where Sarah Jane meets Styre for the first time and mistakes him as Linx were very heart-stopping to watch. I also found the scenes where Sarah Jane gets experimented upon very terrifying, and Lis as Sarah Jane shows how terrified she is.

Ian Marter does really well as Harry Sullivan. Harry gets to be heroic and climbs up lots of cliffs. I enjoyed his scenes with Sarah Jane when they wind each other up. By this point, Sarah Jane and Harry do like each other and it shows in the working relationship between Lis Sladen and Ian Marter.

The story’s guest cast include some human survivors on the planet Earth. They are Donald Douglas as Vural; Glyn Jones (who wrote the First Doctor story ‘The Space Museum’) as Krans; Peter Walshe as Erak; Peter Rutherford as Roth and Terry Walsh as Zake (who doubled for Tom Baker on location).

doctor-who-the-sontaran-experiment-balls

The DVD special features are as follows. The highlight for me is the ‘Built For War – The Sontaran Story’ focusing on the development of the Sontarans in the original TV series. I wish they could update this documentary with the recent TV episodes from the new series and the Big Finish audio dramas.

There’s also an enjoyable commentary with Elisabeth Sladen, producer Phillip Hinchcliffe and co-writer Bob Baker. There’s an info-text commentary option to enjoy and a photo gallery of the story.

Styre_and_Sarah

As I said before, ‘The Sontaran Experiment’ doesn’t rank as one of my favourites, but it’s still an enjoyable adventure. I would recommend this to add to your ‘Doctor Who’ DVD collection as the ‘Built for War’ documentary is excellent and the Doctor, Sarah Jane and Harry are really good in this.

‘The Sontaran Experiment’ rating – 5/10


The previous story

For the Fourth Doctor was

For Sarah Jane was

For Harry was

The next story

For the Fourth Doctor is

For Sarah Jane is

For Harry is

Return to Doctor Who Reviews

2 Responses to ‘The Sontaran Experiment’ (TV)

  1. Timelord-007 says:

    Yeah i was never a fan of the classic series two parters & this one never gets going, this would’ve worked better as a four parter with the Sontarans enslaving the humans on the planet & the Doctor, Sarah & Harry intervene to stop it & repair the transmat which they have to sneak past the camp to get too.

    Excellent review & a fair rating Tim.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Tim Bradley says:

      Sometimes two-parters work, sometimes they don’t. The only two-parter that worked for me was ‘Black Orchid’ and even the audiobook/novelization makes it superior. Clearly these two-part stories should have been made as four-parters, though I can’t say the same for ‘The Edge of Destruction’ 😀

      I’m wondering what Ian Marter’s novelization for this story is like as that must be an extended version of the story with greater detail and development of character.

      Thanks for your kind comments, Timelord Simon. Glad you found my review and rating on this story was fair. Tim. 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s