‘The Rebel Flesh’/’The Almost People’ (TV)

51a5r8ravvl-_ac_ul320_sr228320_  51n1xyjqmkl-_ac_ul320_sr226320_


Please feel free to comment on my review.

Double Trouble with the Eleventh Doctor, Amy and Rory


This is a two-part story by Matthew Graham. It is also the last two-part story of the Matt Smith era!

Matthew Graham previously wrote the ‘Doctor Who’ episode, ‘Fear Her’, with David Tennant’s Doctor. It was nice to have him write a two-part story for the TV series here, and a scary one at that.

This story is set on Earth in the 22nd century, at a monastery converted into a factory. I’m impressed with location work done at Caerphilly Castle in Cardiff, despite the heavy snowfall during the filming.

The Doctor, Amy and Rory crash-land in the TARDIS at this monastery/factory after getting caught in a solar storm. Another solar storm is on its way, and it’s going to get disastrous for the people there.

The focus of the story is on the monsters called the Gangers. These are like flesh avatars based on five humans who are working at the factory. The Gangers go out of control as they gain individuality.

I found the concept of the Gangers pretty frightening. The theme of doubles had been done before in ‘Doctor Who’, but this is on another level as it addresses the themes of identity theft in this story.

There is an element of the movie ‘Avatar’ in this story, which was released not so soon before this two-parter. The dark corridors and creepy atmosphere helped me to appreciate the complexities that are in this.

Matt Smith is good as the Doctor in this. Matt’s Doctor seems to know all about the flesh and about what the gangers are. It was interesting how he knew so much before he, Amy and Rory came here.

Karen Gillan is equally good as Amy here. Amy senses that the Doctor’s hiding something when they come to this factory island on the Earth. She gets on edge especially when the Gangers go walk about.

Arthur Darvill is great as Rory in this. I liked how Rory shows concern for Jennifer in this, as his kindness gets tested here. It was interesting to see how Amy responds to Rory’s concern for Jennifer.

The Gangers are very scary when they reveal themselves in their gloopy form. You can’t help sympathise with them, as they want an identity. But at the same time, they can be very dangerous.

The crew of the factory are led by Raquel Cassidy as Cleaves. She’s a strong personality who takes no-nonsense and wants to be in charge. She refuses to hear the Doctor’s advice when at the factory.

Sarah Smart stands out for me as Jennifer in this story. I like Sarah’s performance as Jennifer, who takes a shine to Rory and rather fancies him. The Ganger version of Jennifer is rather scary and angry.

The guest cast also includes Mark Bonnar as Jimmy; Marshall Lancaster as Buzzer and Leon Vickers as Dicken. Everyone at the factory has a Ganger looking like them, and it’s hard to tell the difference.

There is conflict between the human versions of the factory crew and the Gangers. Eventually one Ganger gets killed by Cleeves and soon the Gangers are on the warpath to kill off their counterparts. Soon, the episode ends on a shocking cliff-hanger. A Ganger version of the Doctor reveals himself!

The DVD special features on this episode are as follows. On Disc 3 of ‘The Complete Series 6’ of ‘Doctor Who’, there’s a commentary with Mark Bonnar, Marshall Lancaster and director Julian Simpson. On Disc 6, there’s the ‘Doctor Who Confidential’ episode, ‘Double Trouble’.


The second episode begins with an intense opening where the Ganger Doctor is getting his memories.

I liked those moments when the Ganger Doctor is saying familiar words from previous Doctors and even sounding like Tom Baker. It was intriguing how the Ganger Doctor and the real Doctor interact.

Matt Smith gets to play double role as the Doctor and the Ganger Doctor in this episode. Both seem to be complimenting each other and finishing off each other’s sentences during some scenes in this.

There is a sense of uneasiness from the surviving human crew and Amy, as they’re unsure which Doctor’s which and whether to trust the Ganger Doctor. It makes it far uneasy for the two Doctors.

I had a job trying to figure out who was who in terms of which Doctor was real and which one was the Ganger. It was pretty confusing and there’s a twist when one of the Doctors switches their shoes.

However, the Ganger Doctor seems to help the real Doctor; Amy and real human crew when dealing with the Ganger revolt. There are moments though when the Ganger Doctor can be pretty unstable.

I liked how Rory’s kindness gets tested in this episode when goes out looking for Jennifer. There’s a tense moment when there are two Jennifers. One gets killed and Rory believes it is the Ganger one.

But it turns out that the Ganger Jennifer has made two versions of herself from the flesh. This means that the Ganger Jennifer lied to Rory. He realises it when she says something the real Jennifer didn’t.

Rory gets very angry and I liked it when he berates Jennifer for lying to him after he abandoned his friends. But Ganger Jennifer doesn’t seem to care as all that matters to her is destroying humanity.

I liked it when the Ganger versions of Cleaves, Jimmy and Dicken refuse to continue in their revolt of Jennifer’s. They don’t want to be the monster she’s become and it’s one of my favourite moments.

Jennifer, out of all the Gangers, turns out to be the monster and she literally transforms into something horrible and nasty. The CGI effects for this monster aren’t great, but they are very scary.

I liked those moments when Jimmy talks to her son and eventually sees him after surviving this nightmare. The real Jimmy died and the Ganger Jimmy gets to be the father which he most deserves.

The episode ends on a very shocking cliff-hanger. Amy is about to go into labour as she’s pregnant. But she’s not the real Amy at all and the Doctor demands Rory to stand back from her in the TARDIS.

The Doctor promises to Amy that he and Rory will find and rescue her, whatever it takes. Soon, the Doctor uses his sonic screwdriver on Amy. She’s revealed to be a flesh Avatar and quickly dissolves.

Then Amy wakes up to find herself in a cubicle, about to give birth. She’s watched by the Eye-Patch Lady who’s been watching her in previous episodes. Amy gives birth and it’s pretty horrifying for her.

The DVD special features on this episode are as follows. On Disc 2 of ‘Series 6 – Part 1’, there’s ‘Monster File: The Gangers’, which looks into the creation and development of these new monsters.

On Disc 3 of ‘The Complete Series 6’ of ‘Doctor Who’, the ‘Monster File: The Gangers’ can also be found on there. On Disc 6, there’s the ‘Doctor Who Confidential’ episode ‘Take Two’.

‘The Rebel Flesh’/’The Almost People’ rating – 8/10

The previous story

For the Eleventh Doctor was

  • ‘Paradox Lost’ (Book/Audio)

For Amy was

  • ‘Paradox Lost’ (Book/Audio)

For Rory was

  • ‘Paradox Lost’ (Book/Audio)
The next story

For the Eleventh Doctor is

For Amy is

For Rory is

Return to The Eleventh Doctor’s Timeline
Return to Amy’s Timeline
Return to Rory’s Timeline
Return to The Doctors’ Timelines Index
Return to The Companions’ Timelines Index
Return to Doctor Who Timelines
Return to Doctor Who
Return to Sci-Fi

5 thoughts on “‘The Rebel Flesh’/’The Almost People’ (TV)

  1. Timelord 007

    My favourite story of this series, i do like it when Doctor Who does creepy scary stories & this two parter more than delivers in thst department, Mark Bonnar of course now plays the disturbed timelord the Eleven in the excellent Doom Coalition series with the Eighth Doctor.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Tim Bradley Post author

    Yes this story is pretty creepy indeed. I enjoyed watching this one and there are plenty of good moments for the characters in this story and not just for the Doctor, Amy and Rory.

    Indeed, this was before Mark Bonnar became the evil Eleven in the ‘Doom Coalition’ series with the Eighth Doctor. I’ve yet to hear those four box set stories. I’m sure they’re very good.

    Thanks for your comments, Simon.

    Tim. 🙂


  3. Timelord007

    Bonnar is brilliant & actually voices all the voices of the Eleven character definitely check that series out Tim you will not be disappointed, I’ve written a couple new reviews & rewritten the Game & Nowhere Place on my G+ page.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Williams Fan 92

    Awesome review Tim!

    I’ve just got done watching these two episodes on BBC iPlayer. I found them both to be really epic and tense. I have already watched ‘A Good Man Goes to War’.

    I agree that Sarah Smart’s performance as Jennifer is a stand out in the story especially considering that she pretty much has the most important role.

    Something I thought I’d tell you (if you don’t know already) is that Sarah starred with Peter Davison in ‘At Home with the Braithwaites’. I mentioned that series on your review of the ‘All Creatures Great and Small’ episode ‘One of Nature’s Little Miracles’ since Lynda Bellingham also starred in it. Sarah portrays the oldest of Peter’s onscreen daughters with her mother being played by actress Amanda Redman who was the wife of Peter’s ‘Sink or Swim’ co-star Robert Glenister. Sarah Smart even once said in an interview that Peter is her favourite Doctor because he played her onscreen father in ‘Braithwaites’. Aside from Sarah and Lynda Bellingham, many other ‘Doctor Who’ guest stars have appeared in ‘Braithwaites’ including Sylvia Syms (Ghost Light), Julie Graham (Ascension of the Cybermen/The Timeless Child) and Judy Holt (The Long Game). I have currently been watching the series on Britbox and found it to be very gripping and tense. If you ever subscribe to Britbox, I’d recommend checking it out there, if not you can buy then watch it on DVD. I’d even like to see you review it on your blog.

    I have also seen Mark Bonnar and Marshall Lancaster in other media. The former I have seen in ‘The Bill’ and ‘Quiz’, and the latter I have seen in ‘Life on Mars’ (with John Simm and Robert Glenister’s brother Philip) and ‘Ashes to Ashes’ both of which where written by Matthew Graham.

    Take care, WF92.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Tim Bradley Post author

      Hi WF92.

      Glad you enjoyed watching this two-part story recently on BBC iPlayer. I’ve changed my rating on the story from 7/10 to 8/10 as it is one of the good stories featured in Series 6 of ‘Doctor Who’. I’m glad Sarah Smart’s performance as Jennifer stood out for you from this story as well as for me.

      I didn’t know Sarah Smart was in ‘At Home with the Braithwaites’ with Peter Davison. Thanks for letting me know about that. I’ve yet to see the series. Thanks for recommending it to me. I’m slowly warming to the idea of subscribing to Britbox at some point. I would like to check out the anniversary episodes of ‘Thundebirds’ that are on Britbox. I’ll certainly consider checking out ‘At Home with the Braithwaites’ whether it’d be on DVD or Britbox.

      Many thanks for your comments.

      Tim. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.