‘Victory of the Daleks’ (TV)

‘VICTORY OF THE DALEKS’

Please feel free to comment on my review.

Go, Go Power Daleks

Oh dear! ‘Victory of the Daleks’! This was a wasted opportunity on many levels. I wish I could say Matt Smith’s first encounter with the Daleks was great! But this ‘Doctor Who’ tale did fall flat for me.

The episode is by Matt Gatiss, a very good ‘Doctor Who’ writer. Set in 1940s London during World War II, the Doctor and Amy meet Winston Churchill, who is now working in the Cabinet War Rooms.

Churchill asked for the Doctor’s help in ‘The Beast Below’, but he arrived in the TARDIS a month late. The Doctor and Amy soon see that the British Army have a new secret weapon called the Ironsides.

But the Ironsides happen to be Daleks. The Doctor is not happy when he sees them. He knows the Daleks are up to something. They keep saying “I am your soldier!” and they do not know the Doctor.

I do like the Ironside Daleks where they’re painted khaki-green, similar to British army soldiers in World War II. If only the Daleks stayed like that throughout the episode, as they’re more interesting.

There is a sense of an atmosphere echoed from ‘The Power of the Daleks’, especially when the Daleks seem to be serving humanity. But the Doctor sees through their cover and it’s over so quickly.

Once the Doctor’s given a ‘testimony’ to allow the Daleks to activate their progenitor, the Daleks on Earth return to their spaceship hidden behind the moon. There, they continue with their evil plans.

It turns out that these Daleks survived the events of ‘The Stolen Earth’/’Journey’ End’ when the Doctor comes to their spaceship to face them. The Daleks use their progenitor to restore their race.

And this is where my disappointment of the episode comes into place. This episode features the first appearance of the New Paradigm Daleks that come out of the progenitor machine on the spaceship.

And they’re awful! Honestly, I don’t like these new Paradigm Daleks in the episode. They’re bigger and fatter than the normal Daleks. I know some readers of ‘Doctor Who Magazine’ didn’t like them.

The idea was to have multi-coloured Daleks echo the 1960s movies with Peter Cushing. Except these don’t look anything like Daleks, with their eyestalks and big ‘busts’! (I didn’t think I would say that!!!)

When I look at the new Paradigm Daleks, they put me in mind of ‘Power Rangers’. Seriously! These Daleks could have their own TV show called ‘Mighty Morphin’ Power Daleks’ should it ever be made.

The Daleks of saving grace are the Ironsides and the bronze Dalek aboard the spaceship. If only they lasted longer! But nope! They get destroyed instantly by the new Paradigm Daleks! Destroyed! Argh!

And there’s another thing I don’t like about this episode. There are flying Spitfires…in outer space! Flying Spitfires in outer space?! No, no! Sorry! I can’t buy it! That’s just silly and ridiculous to think of.

Is there anything I like about this episode? Well, yes actually. Ian McNeice is very good as Winston Churchill in the episode. I’ve met Ian McNiece in real life at the ‘Worcester Comic Con’, August 2016.

There’s also Bill Paterson as Professor Bracewell in the episode. I first saw Bill Paterson in the BBC adaptation of ‘Wives and Daughters’ and he would later play Frazer in the ‘Dad’s Army’ film in 2016.

And Matt Smith and Karen Gillan give decent performances as the Doctor and Amy. I like how they interact with Churchill and how they emotionally connect to Bracewell when he is about to explode.

There’s something interesting about this episode in connection to Amy. She doesn’t remember the Dalek invasion of Earth with planets in the sky from ‘The Stolen Earth’/’Journey’s End’. Why is that?

‘Victory of the Daleks’ is a disappointing episode with the metallic pepperpots. I didn’t like the New Paradigm Daleks back then in 2010 and I still don’t like them now. It was a wasted opportunity here.

The DVD special features on this episode are as follows. On the ‘Series 5, Volume 1’ DVD, there’s ‘Monster File: The Daleks’ which looks into the creation and development of the New Paradigm Daleks.

On Disc 2 of ‘The Complete Series 5’ of ‘Doctor Who’, the ‘Monster File: The Daleks’ can also be found on there. There’s also an in-vision commentary with writer Mark Gattis, Dalek voice artist Nicholas Briggs and Dalek operator Barnaby Edwards.

On Disc 6, there’s the ‘Doctor Who Confidential’ episode ‘War Games’.

The first three TV episodes of Matt Smith’s era of ‘Doctor Who’ start the era well. With the exception of ‘Victory of the Daleks’, the new Matt Smith/Steven Moffat era looked promising. I was hoping to get more into this new era and find out what would happen next. Would this new era get better for me?

‘Victory of the Daleks’ rating – 4/10


The previous story

For the Eleventh Doctor was

For Amy was

The next story

For the Eleventh Doctor is

  • ‘Apollo 23’ (Book/Audio)

For Amy is

  • ‘Apollo 23’ (Book/Audio)
Return to The Eleventh Doctor’s Timeline
Return to Amy’s Timeline
Return to The Doctors’ Timelines Index
Return to The Companions’ Timelines Index
Return to Doctor Who Timelines
Return to Doctor Who
Return to Sci-Fi

2 thoughts on “‘Victory of the Daleks’ (TV)

  1. Timelord 007

    You so got this review spot on Tim, Paradigm Daleks….PARADIGM DALEKS……..RAAAAAAAAAAGGGGGGGGEEEEEE I HATE THEM, FAT TELLYTUBBY DALEKS DAMM YOU MOFFAT!!.

    I detest these Daleks, they look utterly ridiculous & cheap looking & not a patch on the original design

    Anyway the first half of this story is good & i loved Matt’s performance as he starts hitting the Dalek with a spanner & shows his Doctor has genuine hatred towards the Daleks.

    Ian McNeice is very good as Winston Churchill in the episode & it’s a shame he appeared only a couple more times in the Matt Smith era.

    But then the whole plot gets convoluted with Spitfires in space & those horrific monstrosities multi coloured Daleks & the whole thing loses it’s way & becomes a very lacklustre effort especially the syrupy conclusion with Professor Bracewell oh look he’s a robot.

    Urgh bloody Paradigm Daleks your right there Mighty Morphin Power Ranger Daleks….oh i need a lie down in the zero room.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
  2. Tim Bradley Post author

    Hi Simon.

    I knew the Paradigm Daleks wouldn’t agree with you either. I’m pleased you agree with my thoughts in the review.

    I was dismayed to see how these new Daleks looked and was disappointed when I saw the Ironsides and the bronze Dalek destroyed instantly by the Paradigms. I would have preferred the bronze Daleks and the Ironsides throughout this episode, rather than the Paradigms.

    I wouldn’t mind seeing the Daleks being multi-coloured and bigger, if they at least stuck to the original design, not change their eye-stalks and give them huge busts (eek!). I recall seeing an animation YouTube video of the new Paradigm Daleks as they should be in their proper design.

    In fact, this is the YouTube video here for you to see by Dark Raven Productions:

    Yes Matt Smith’s Doctor does well in facing the Daleks in this episode. He’s truly serious when he shows how he hates the Daleks and that scene where he hits a Dalek with a spanner was pretty tense and dramatic to watch.

    Yeah it is a shame that Ian McNeice’s Winston Churchill appear only a few times in the Matt Smith era of ‘Doctor Who’. But at least he’s now got his own CD series of ‘Doctor Who’ in ‘The Churchill Years’ box sets, which I’m sure many ‘Doctor Who’ fans enjoy.

    The thing that annoys me about those Spitfires is that it took Bracewell no time to build these things. It’s as if he used his magic wand to build them and there didn’t seem to be anytime for these Spitfires to be tested into space. Also, the fact that Danny Boy and the other Spitfire pilots aren’t wearing proper space suits in the planes is ludicrous. The “Tally ho!” dialogue also grates me as it just sounds so silly.

    I don’t mind Bill Paterson’s performance as Bracewell in the episode, as I enjoyed seeing him in this from seeing ‘Wives and Daughters’. But you are right, the plot gets convoluted and lacklustre in order to appreciate the emotional impact of this episode. The fact that he’s also a robot and built by the Daleks doesn’t mean he can get used again to turn on his own kind. Oops, Doctor; Amy. Maybe you should have dismantled him. Sigh.

    I’m glad you agree that the new Paradigm Daleks are like the Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers. Don’t get me wrong, I love that TV show and am currently watching it for the review. But this is a different style of action-packed TV story that needs to be taken seriously, despite some of the goofy elements it has. And having the new Paradigm Daleks doesn’t help much.

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this episode, Simon. I’m glad you agree with me.

    Tim. 🙂

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.